Tuesday, September 1, 2009

Thome to L.A.

Our old friend Jim Thome has been traded again. The White Sox sent him to the Dodgers to rejoin his former teammate Manny Ramirez. We all remember how devastating those guys were when hitting back-to-back in their 20s. Now they're both in their late 30s, and both can still hit the ball hard, if maybe not quite as often as they used to. It will be bittersweet to see them together again, wearing something other than Tribe unis.

But consider this: Unless Thome is ever hit with steroid allegations, he's a sure-fire Hall of Famer. He spent 12 years in Cleveland, three years in Philadelphia, and now 3 1/2 in Chicago. I don't know how long he'll be in L.A., but it won't be 12 years. He'll have Chief Wahoo on his Hall plaque.

I know, that doesn't change the fact that he left for more money after the 2002 season because the Phillies offered him more money, after saying he wanted to do whatever he could to stay in Cleveland. But as I said at the time (to friends; I didn't have a blog then), you and I would most likely have done the exact same thing.

Thome is currently 12th on the all-time home run list, with 564. Home run totals in this era don't mean as much as they used to, but if he's been clean his whole career, that's a very impressive total. Among those ahead of him are Barry Bonds, Sammy Sosa, Mark McGwire, Alex Rodriguez and Rafael Palmeiro, all of whom are known to have taken performance-enhancing drugs. Manny is behind Thome on the career list, but his numbers carry that taint as well. The only other recent player ahead of Thome is Ken Griffey Jr. If both those guys are clean (which we don't know and may never), we probably have seriously undervalued their careers because of the era in which they played.

Regardless, I wish Thome well, and will always remember his time in Cleveland fondly. May he have success in Los Angeles.

3 comments:

lisa said...

Seems you could get away with being a Dodgers fan, and not feel you are betraying the Indians, with all the former Indians players on that team right now...

Steve Mullett said...

You're quite right, Lisa! In addition to Thome and Ramirez, the Dodgers have Casey Blake, and they also just traded for Ronnie Belliard. And they have Jeff Weaver, who was once in the Tribe's minor-league system. It's like Cleveland west over there!

Jeff Brown said...

Mullett, the Dodgers now have two active players with a joint total of 1109 home runs.

That's got to be a record for the most career HRs for two teammates, wouldn't you think?

(and yes, they have Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth beaten. When Ruth retired after the 1935 season, their joint total stood at 1092)